Separating AI hype from reality.

Senate Passes Sweeping Energy Permitting Bill, Sending Data Center Cost Fight to House

November 21, 2026 · Data centers · Energy · Regulation

The U.S. Senate approved the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA) on Thursday in a 62-33 vote, advancing the most significant overhaul of federal energy permitting in decades. The legislation now heads to the House, where its fate is uncertain despite a coalition of moderate Democrats signaling support.

The bill passed with 47 Republicans and 14 or 15 Democrats voting in favor [3][4][8][9]. It was negotiated by Sens. Shelley Moore Capito (R-W.Va.), Mike Lee (R-Utah), Martin Heinrich (D-N.M.) and Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.) a few weeks before the midterm elections that gave Democrats control of both chambers [2][3]. President Trump endorsed the bill, calling it a "BIG WIN for U.S. ENERGY INDEPENDENCE and DOMINANCE" [2][8].

What the bill does

BAAJA shortens environmental review deadlines under the National Environmental Policy Act, limits the alternatives agencies must consider, and narrows the scope of projects triggering review [7]. It compresses the window to file legal challenges to 150 days and restricts courts' ability to halt projects — even if a review is found deficient — under NEPA, the Clean Water Act and the Endangered Species Act [6].

The bill expands the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's authority to issue construction permits for interstate transmission lines when states block or delay them [1][6]. It accelerates permitting for geothermal, hydropower, offshore wind and renewable projects, while also removing federal permit requirements for onshore oil and gas drilling on non-federal land [1].

"Permit certainty" provisions bar future administrations from vacating issued permits except in emergencies, and allow developers to sue agencies for "disparate treatment" of energy technologies [6].

Data centers: ratepayer protection with a potential loophole

The bill's most politically salient provision directs FERC to establish ratepayer protections for data centers exceeding 20 megawatts, requiring them to pay for grid upgrades they necessitate and for their use of existing transmission [1][4]. Grid Strategies estimates the changes would collect an additional $35 billion from data centers over ten years, $55 billion total [4].

"Data centers create well-paying jobs, generate substantial tax revenue, advance innovation, can lower electricity rates for other ratepayers," the Data Center Coalition said in a statement [4].

But the bill does not address behind-the-meter generation. McKinsey found 60% of North American data center operators plan on-site power plants, mostly gas-fired, to bypass grid interconnection queues [4]. BloombergNEF estimates roughly 100 gigawatts of gas capacity planned at data centers; Earthjustice puts the figure at 177 GW [4]. If built, nine of the ten largest U.S. power plants would serve data centers on-site [4].

"The bill is not addressing that at all," said Meg Slattery of Earthjustice. "The models that model the emissions impacts of the bill do not account for behind-the-meter generation" [4].

Competing emissions claims

Four major modeling studies project BAAJA would add 17–325 GW of clean capacity by 2035–2040 [5]. Power-sector emissions reductions vary across studies: Rhodium Group projects 1–18% by 2040 [6], while Resources for the Future models 6–15% reductions in different timeframes [5]. C2ES/Greenline Insights projects 13% by 2035, and SEIA projects 20% cumulative reductions 2028–2035 [5]. Rhodium projects economy-wide reductions of 5–148 million metric tons CO2e annually by 2040, with household bills $50–78 lower [5]. Resources for the Future models a 3.5–7% lower power system cost [5].

But Rhodium's "High Emissions" scenario shows up to 8 GW more gas capacity and 8–15% higher LNG exports, with overseas combustion emissions uncounted [5]. Resources for the Future shows a near-term increase in combined-cycle gas plants [5]. The studies cover only modeled provisions, not the full bill [5].

Democratic fracture and tribal opposition

The vote exposed a deep Democratic split. Sens. Jeff Merkley and Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) pushed amendments to ban data centers on federal land and block the Trump administration from canceling clean energy grants; Republican leaders blocked votes on all amendments [2][8]. Sens. Raphael Warnock (D-Ga.) and Alex Padilla (D-Calif.) voted no [3][8]. Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto (D-Nev.) voted yes but said the bill "ignores Tribal input" [3], though Latitude Media reported she voted no over tribal consultation provisions [6] — a discrepancy the sources do not resolve.

"This bill doesn't just roll out the red carpet for data center developers, it puts them on a greased-up slide into towns across America," Markey said [4].

Tribal nations object to changes in the National Historic Preservation Act and consultation rights. The Oneida Nation said the bill "threatens the tribe's ability to protect its sacred spaces, ancestors, traditional ceremonies and culture" [8]. Former Energy Secretary Jennifer Granholm argued recent changes "strengthen protections for tribal consultation and restore important state authority over water quality" [8].

House prospects

The House passed a narrower, industry-friendly permitting bill last year [8]. Rep. Scott Peters (D-Calif.) urged passage: "There will be no better deal on the table... With Donald Trump in the White House and 60 required votes in the Senate, bipartisanship is unavoidable" [3]. Reps. Jared Huffman (D-Calif.) and Rashida Tlaib (D-Mich.) argue Democrats should wait for the new Congress [6].

What happens next is unclear. The House may amend the bill, requiring another Senate vote. If passed, Trump has signaled he would sign it. Whether the data center grid-cost provisions survive intact, and whether the behind-the-meter gas loophole gets closed, remains unresolved.

Sources

  1. US Senate passes bill requiring data centers to pay more for grid ... (datacenterdynamics.com)
  2. Senate backs bill to speed up permitting reviews (kcra.com)
  3. Permitting reform bill heads to House as Democratic divisions persist (utilitydive.com)
  4. Data Center Impact Hotly Contested in Federal Permitting Fight (insideclimatenews.org)
  5. Expert Q&A: What a New Transmission and Permitting Bill Means for Energy ... (wri.org)
  6. Senate clears permitting reform after a bitter split among greens (latitudemedia.com)
  7. Senate passes bipartisan permitting overhaul bill (dailyenergyinsider.com)
  8. Senate approves bipartisan bill to overhaul US energy sectors | AP News (apnews.com)
  9. Senate passes bipartisan energy bill amid environmental concerns : NPR (npr.org)
  10. ENR and EPW Democrats’ Summary of Changes Contained in Substitute AmendmentENR and EPW Democrats’ Summary of Changes Contained in Substitute Amendment (heinrich.senate.gov)