Senate and Commerce Department Escalate Pressure on Nvidia Chip Diversion to China
Senator Maria Cantwell sent a letter on November 15 — reported as Sunday by some outlets and Monday by others — demanding that Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick use existing authority to block restricted chips from reaching barred companies. The Commerce Department published an interim rule on Monday requiring licenses for exports of advanced semiconductors to five countries — Brazil, Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, and Thailand — that BIS says present a higher-than-normal risk of diversion, and imposing due-diligence requirements on overseas data centers serving companies in countries such as China, Russia, Iran, and Cuba [3][4][10].
Cantwell's letter: enforcement gaps and financial questions
Cantwell's letter cites the Export Control Reform Act of 2018 as the basis for Commerce's existing powers to investigate violations and restrict companies deemed national-security threats [1][9]. She argues the department has "resisted efforts to restrict companies flagged as national security threats, weakened safeguards, and left open pathways for the PRC to train advanced AI models using sensitive American technology" [9].
The letter details four specific failures:
- Overseas data-center loophole: The Financial Times reported that Alibaba and ByteDance used foreign data centers equipped with advanced Nvidia chips to train models, exploiting a gap in export controls. Despite warnings from the Bureau of Industry and Security, Commerce did not close the loophole [9].
- Megaspeed delays: White House and intelligence officials reportedly urged Commerce to restrict Megaspeed, a Singapore-based company accused of smuggling restricted chips to China, beginning in fall 2025. A classified warning was delivered in May 2026; Commerce did not act. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent publicly confirmed that Treasury, Defense, State, and the U.S. Trade Representative supported restricting Megaspeed for months [9].
- Suspended investigation: Commerce investigators were examining Megaspeed when Nvidia's general counsel contacted them in August 2025. The department suspended its administrative investigation after the Justice Department requested the matter be transferred for criminal investigation, leaving Megaspeed free to continue obtaining chips [9].
- Subsidiary rule suspended: In September 2025, BIS extended export restrictions to subsidiaries majority-owned by restricted companies. Commerce suspended that rule in November 2025 and extended the suspension through January 10, 2027, preserving a pathway for restricted entities to seek U.S. technology through affiliates [9].
Cantwell also raised two financial concerns. She said the administration's 25% fee on certain Nvidia chips sold to China creates a "perverse financial incentive to approve exports of sensitive American technology" [1][9]. Separately, she noted that Cantor Fitzgerald, the firm controlled by Lutnick's sons, held $1.2 billion in Nvidia stock at the time of his nomination — a potential conflict, not a finding of wrongdoing [1][9].
Commerce had not responded to CNBC's request for comment by November 16 [1].
Interim rule targets remote access and reexport risk
The interim rule, issued Monday, aims to "ensure that existing restrictions on access to sensitive American technology cannot be circumvented through remote computing arrangements involving data centers in third countries" [10]. It adds a licensing requirement for exporting, reexporting, or transferring advanced semiconductors to Brazil, Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, and Thailand — countries BIS says "present a higher-than-normal risk of diversion" [10]. Overseas data centers serving companies in countries such as China, Russia, Iran, and Cuba must now perform "robust due diligence" on their customers [3].
The rule aligns remote-access protections with controls governing physical access to sensitive technology [10]. It follows the Nvidia scandal: Huang resigned last week amid revelations of an affair with Alice Huang, then-CEO of Megaspeed, whom U.S. intelligence suspects is a Chinese spy [3][5][9]. China has denied the allegations [6].
Conflicting signals from the White House
President Trump departed Monday for the Philippines and China, where he will meet Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin this week. On the South Lawn, Trump said Lutnick has "done a very good job" and he has no plans to fire him. He added he "wouldn't mind" seeing Huang return to Nvidia [2], and expressed skepticism that Alice Huang is a spy: "Nobody has proven that," he said. "She may not be." [3] Trump also said he did not want to offend China with chip restrictions ahead of the summit [2].
Yet the interim rule's publication included language that it was written at the behest of Treasury and the National Security Council — an indication the White House bypassed Lutnick, who favors fewer limits, to get it done [2]. Lutnick is traveling with Trump to Asia, as is Bessent, who has publicly criticized Commerce's delay on Megaspeed [2][6].
What remains uncertain
- Whether Commerce will act on Cantwell's demand to enforce existing restrictions against Megaspeed and other flagged entities.
- Whether the interim rule's licensing and due-diligence requirements will be enforced consistently across the five newly listed countries.
- The extent of any financial influence on export decisions; Cantwell's letter raises concerns but does not allege proven misconduct.
- How the Trump-Xi meeting will affect export policy, given the president's public reluctance to tighten controls before the summit.
The dual moves reflect a bureaucracy pulling in two directions: a congressional demand for stricter enforcement of current law, and an administrative rule that closes a technical loophole while the president signals a preference for accommodation.
Sources
- Cantwell presses Lutnick to enforce AI-chip controls, citing ... (superpowerdaily.com)
- The Nvidia scandal, according to Trump (politico.com)
- Trump will head to Asia for economic deals and historic ... (washingtonpost.com)
- US Limits Remote Access to Advanced AI Chips (briefs.co)
- Live updates: Trump en route to Asia; Nvidia scandal ... (thehill.com)
- The Latest: Trump will head to Asia for economic deals and ... (sitkasentinel.com)
- AI news today: models, products and research | Pim Uijttewaal (pimuijttewaal.nl)
- Anatomy of the FAA Ground Stop: One Backbone, One Bad ... (bankinfosecurity.com)
- Senator slams Commerce Secretary for flow of Nvidia AI chips to China | The Verge (theverge.com)
- After Nvidia scandal, Commerce Department moves to curb remote access to AI chips - CBS News (cbsnews.com)